Who had the Broken ABility

[ATruGambit]

i left off hilary and jangler acuse thier abilities didnt seem so obad

also i have proposed changes to some abilities and stats if we choose to continue this

i'll hold off on posting them until i see the results for who we think needs tweaking

also please keep in mind, rate the ability, not the deck.

[CRASHER]

blah... this is a tough one... all the abilites were fairly decent
(with the exception of the mis-read on Edge-Hamus's ability)
Brian's ability is kinda powerful too.. esp since he is so damn good at getting hand intelligence... possible adjusters to
brian:

1. Make it he can only make you lose a non-unique reversal maybe ?
2. Discard 2 for the ability ??

Not sure on this... but man it does run itself goofy having
infinite cole calls it power for the game.

Also we know what NEEDS be fixed on EdgeHamus' ability
right (he discards a card to recover two of the same type and I am tempted to say non-unique too since it's a modified JR Clubbering it should be treated so)

I didn't see all the decks in action but other then that I'd call it a mild success !!! I'd like to make this the format in our league if possible.

and NO I have not voted here yet

[ATruGambit]

wel lthe proposed changes i had in mind.

brian dropping 2 for his ability ( he has the carddraw so its not an issue for him relaly)

mike getting at least an official 9 or 10 handsize. his hand does get torn through VERY fast

edgamus having to DISCARD 1 to shuffle 2 is fine for me

and

Whisp this should make you happy. you lose the ability to search for whips. but they regain thier set up trait. meaning you can pack more of them. also as it is you have 3 whips ad 3 cards that require whips which i enver liked, i always liked more stock than need. also your proposed specifics require wips too so it means, as it stands now. you'll have 3 whips and 5 manuevers that require whip.

[Jayson"Phonics"]

Brian's feud needs to be changed some too. Being able to do one of his 3 options everytime any CARD hits his ring area is a bit much, perhaps making it just his maniuevers he does one of those 3 options.

[StonePolhamusCold]

Just look at my Personalized T&B Cards, you'll understand that if my Action/Reversal Hybrid is allowed, then I won't need more than 3 Whips.

[President B. Dazzle]

Jayson"Phonics" said:

Brian's feud needs to be changed some too. Being able to do one of his 3 options everytime any CARD hits his ring area is a bit much, perhaps making it just his maniuevers he does one of those 3 options.

I take serious exception to this. It was broken in its original format, no doubt. But the limit of twice per turn and the hitting the ring area part, in my opinion, makes it balanced. Yeah, it helps my deck, but if a feud didn't help me (or hinder you), then why should I play it? You're saying they never should have made Angle's feud because it's powerful?

Maybe, MAYBE my ability needs a bit more drawback, but the thing is that it rips my hand apart as it is, and I don't replace the cards all that easily. I disagree, because a) there are existing ways around my ability that have other uses, which Mike and LaFlamme (at least) both packed, and b) the deck build helped me a hell of a lot, since I cut down on the number of reversals I needed to worry about in hand at the start of the game and built from there. (Anyone who disputes this should recall the attempt at a Throw/Series deck and remember how bad that was.) It's like saying LaFlamme's ability is broken because he went and got the Edge-a-Cution every other turn to discard. (and we know that's just deck-building, not broken-ness)

Anyways, I await your responses, as I think I've said my piece for now.